New Columbus Pizza Co. | Wood-Fired Pizza & Family Tradition in Nesquehoning
New Columbus Pizza Co. in Nesquehoning, PA serves authentic wood-fired pizza rooted in decades of family tradition. The Cerimele family has been in the food business since the 1950s. Their original recipes continue to shape every pie made today.
Owner Tony Cerimele carries that tradition forward while refining his craft. As a member of the World Pizza Champions, he has competed nationally and earned recognition for his skills. His experience and training are reflected in each pizza, from the light, airy crust to the signature sauce and cheese blend.
The shop specializes in Neapolitan-inspired, wood-fired pizzas made fresh every Friday. Each pie is baked to order, delivering a crisp texture and bold flavor. In addition to pizza, the menu includes strombolis and subs for those looking for classic options. Customers can call ahead to place orders and check weekly specials on social media.
New Columbus Pizza Co. also offers mobile wood-fired pizza catering for private events and gatherings. This service brings their signature pizzas directly to celebrations, adding a unique touch to any occasion.
Menu Highlights
The Red Original highlights the family’s long-standing sauce recipe with a classic approach. The Open Face White pairs cheese, onions, and rosemary for a simple, balanced flavor. Specialty options like the Shrimp & Hot Peppers pizza add a bold twist, while rotating creations and weekly features keep the menu fresh.
New Columbus Pizza Co. in Nesquehoning delivers wood-fired pizza backed by family tradition and award-winning craftsmanship in the Pocono Mountains.
