Since 2001, this Old Forge favorite has been serving homemade trays of that famous, delicious square style pizza. Mary Lou’s Pizza prides itself on using tried and true family recipes that continually land this little shop on many local favorites lists. Call ahead and get your pizza to go or stop in, grab a table and enjoy the stylishly understated dining space. In addition to delicious pizza, Mary Lou’s also features homemade breads and pastas.

Menu Highlights

It’s Old Forge pizza. You get the red or the white. Fortunately, at Mary Lou’s you can’t go wrong with either choice. The red consists of a fluffy, light crust, tangy red sauce and piles of delicious cheese. And you have to try the double crust white. It’s basically an unbelievably tasty pillow of heaven that you can eat.

Customers also rave about both the shrimp and hot pepper pizza, and the seasonal fresh tomato pizza. For those who enjoy toppings, order broccoli, spinach, pepperoni or even a tray with peppers, mushrooms & sausage.