Papa’s Primo Pizza is a cozy hometown pizza parlor in downtown Honesdale. They’ve been tossing New York-style pies and making traditional Italian dishes since 1991. They also serve subs, salads, wraps, and sandwiches. Whether you dine in or order take out, their huge menu is sure to please the entire family.

Papa’s Primo Pizza is also home to Sweet Susie’s, an ice cream shop that serves Manning’s ice cream, Italian ice, gelatti, and other frozen treats. They’re open year-round.

Menu Highlights

The specialty pizzas are a great choice for the whole family. Try gourmet pizzas like the chicken cordon bleu pizza covered with chicken, ham, cheese, and creamy alfredo sauce. The Ol’ Brooklyn pie is an old-school pizza topped with olive oil, fresh mozzarella, and a special blend of spices.

Nothing beats authentic Italian cuisine. Try the homemade cheese lasagna if you’re craving some comfort food.

Photography by: Courtney Snyder